Not every great game gets the spotlight it deserves. In this guide, we’ll explore the most underrated PS5 games—titles that flew under the radar but deliver incredible experiences. Whether you’re into action, RPGs, indies, or creative adventures, these hidden gems are worth adding to your library.
Introduction
The PS5 library has exploded since its launch, with massive hits like Spider-Man 2, Elden Ring, and Final Fantasy XVI grabbing headlines. But what about the games that didn’t trend on Twitter or get Game of the Year nods—yet still offer amazing gameplay? This guide is dedicated to those quiet heroes: the most underrated PS5 games you shouldn’t miss in 2025.
1) Kena: Bridge of Spirits
Why it’s underrated: Released quietly during the PS5’s early years, Kena is a breathtaking action-adventure with Pixar-like visuals. Many skipped it in favor of bigger blockbusters.
Why it’s worth it: Emotional storytelling, creative puzzles, and Rot companions make it one of the most heartwarming PS5 adventures.
Playtime: 10–15 hours
2) Returnal
Why it’s underrated: Though it received critical acclaim, many players avoided it due to its difficulty and roguelike systems.
Why it’s worth it: It’s a masterclass in tension, with fluid gunplay, haunting visuals, and a gripping sci-fi narrative. The PS5’s 3D audio makes it unforgettable.
Playtime: 30–60 hours
3) Sackboy: A Big Adventure
Why it’s underrated: Overshadowed by Astro’s Playroom and bigger platformers, Sackboy slipped under the radar.
Why it’s worth it: Charming, family-friendly, and surprisingly deep in co-op. A must for platforming fans.
Playtime: 15–20 hours
4) Ghostwire: Tokyo
Why it’s underrated: Released during a busy season and with mixed reviews, many skipped this spooky open-world adventure.
Why it’s worth it: Tokyo has never looked better. Unique finger-weaving combat and eerie atmosphere make it a hidden gem.
Playtime: 20–30 hours
5) Immortals Fenyx Rising
Why it’s underrated: Launched alongside Assassin’s Creed Valhalla and Cyberpunk 2077, it was overshadowed.
Why it’s worth it: A colorful, witty take on Greek mythology with Zelda-inspired puzzles and traversal.
Playtime: 25–40 hours
6) Deathloop
Why it’s underrated: Despite stylish marketing, it didn’t hold mainstream attention for long.
Why it’s worth it: Smart time-loop mechanics, bold art direction, and creative assassination strategies.
Playtime: 15–25 hours
7) The Pathless
Why it’s underrated: Released with little fanfare, The Pathless never gained the audience it deserved.
Why it’s worth it: Gorgeous art style, fluid movement mechanics, and a peaceful yet adventurous vibe.
Playtime: 8–12 hours
8) Stray
Why it’s underrated: Despite viral buzz about “the cat game,” some dismissed it as a gimmick.
Why it’s worth it: Stray is atmospheric, emotional, and unique—offering perspective like no other game.
Playtime: 6–10 hours
9) Little Devil Inside (2025 Update)
Why it’s underrated: After delays, it launched quietly and didn’t get mass coverage.
Why it’s worth it: Stylish visuals, quirky humor, and survival exploration blend into a distinctive experience.
Playtime: 15–25 hours
10) Steelrising
Why it’s underrated: Released in the shadow of bigger soulslikes.
Why it’s worth it: A unique alternate-history Paris with mechanical enemies and satisfying combat for Souls fans.
Playtime: 20–30 hours
Honorable Mentions
- Tchia: A charming island adventure with music and exploration.
- Nioh Collection: Remasters of two incredible samurai action RPGs.
- Solar Ash: Stylish, fluid traversal and combat.
- Judgment & Lost Judgment: Yakuza spin-offs full of detective action.
Why These Gems Get Overlooked
- Overshadowed by giants: Smaller games often release alongside blockbusters.
- Genre misconceptions: Roguelikes, indies, and experimental styles turn away casual players.
- Marketing gaps: Without big ad budgets, some games slip under the radar.
But often, these overlooked titles become cult classics—and discovering them early is part of the fun.
How to Find More Underrated PS5 Games
- Explore PlayStation Plus Extra & Premium libraries—hidden gems are added monthly.
- Check indie showcases like Day of the Devs or State of Play.
- Follow smaller YouTube/Twitch creators who spotlight niche titles.
- Join gaming forums like ResetEra and Reddit for community recommendations.
Final Thoughts
The PS5 is known for its blockbuster hits, but the real treasure lies in the hidden corners of its library. These are the most underrated PS5 games you shouldn’t miss—games that deliver heart, creativity, and unique mechanics that rival any big-budget release. If you’re looking for something fresh, it’s time to dive into these gems.
